Is It Cake? Halloween

Mikey Day Self - Host Ravi Patel Self - Judge Chelsea Peretti Self - Judge Pete Holmes Self - Judge Melissa Joan Hart Self - Judge Jack McBrayer Self - Judge Yvonne Orji Self - Judge Harvey Guillén Self - Judge Gillian Jacobs Self - Judge Kevin Nealon Self - Judge Whitney Cummings Self - Judge Rachel Feinstein Self - Judge